Oct 23, 2014 03:06am
Transgender issues and restroom access
Date: 
May 27, 2012 - 6:12pm

Safe Zone and Triangle Alliance members ignited conversations about discrimination against transgender people and the use of public restrooms due to a campus incident in March, which uncovered the lack of awareness and knowledge about transgender people on campus.trans symbol

  The incident involved a male EvCC student entering the woman’s shower and restroom in the Fitness Center between March 13 and 15.

  On March 15 the student was arrested and later charged with voyeurism for viewing, photographing and filming at least five individuals without their consent.

  On the day of his arrest, the student entered the woman’s restroom wearing a long-haired wig and a stuffed bra, portraying himself as a woman. The student has since been suspended.

  Safe Zone, a program that strives to erase homophobia and heterosexism, raised a question from this experience. While his behavior was criminal and nobody disputes this, there was concern that a transgender person – a person who is biologically one gender, but identifies as another – using the bathroom is going to raise the same suspicion.

  Allison Cohen, Director of Healthcare Pathways Center and a Safe Zone member, explained that suspicion should result from a person’s behavior, not the way they look or how they dress.

  “I think we need to broaden what our norm is around gender identity, so [if] you see someone who doesn’t conform to your idea of what your gender should express, then there’s awareness that there’s actually a broader definition,” Cohen said.

  As of 2006, Washington State Law for Freedom of Discrimination (RCW 49.60) specifically states transgender people are legally allowed to use the “public wash rooms” they gender identify with. Otherwise meaning, that a man who identifies himself as a woman, has the right to use a women’s restroom.

  Washington is one of 16 states with this law. There are also 143 city and county laws addressing the same situation nationwide. Washington D.C. also has a similar law.

  Many people are unaware of this law, including Triangle Alliance members. Triangle Alliance is a club for LGBTQ (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and questioning/queer) students and allies.

  “I feel like I’m a man, but I have to use the woman’s bathroom because that’s what people see me as,” said Kat Stillwell, EvCC student and a member of Triangle Alliance.

  Lindsay Krill, vice president of the club, explained she’s worried about how the voyeurism incident has affected people who trans-identify, despite what the law says.

  She’s concerned students and faculty will assume transgender people using the restroom have the same negative intentions based on how they look, especially “if they don’t look enough like a woman to be passing”.

  “It’s happened before, so women will be more frightened,” Krill said.
  Safe Zone members continue to discuss ways to create an environment that is welcoming to all students.  In fact, Cohen said people have showed more interest in the committee since the incident.

  Safe Zone plans to create a sub-committee that will focus on evaluating where the one-stall restrooms are located on campus, which can also be considered gender-neutral restrooms.

  The committee will also look into the possible need to create more of these restrooms and have also discussed the possibility of establishing a gender-neutral shower area in the Fitness Center.

  There are currently two gender-neutral restrooms in Whitehorse Hall, one in the Fitness Center and one in Parks Student Union.

  Others like Stillwell would like to see signs posted in front of the restrooms explaining transgender people are welcome, because of the lack of knowledge within the community.

  It’s important for Cohen not to just look at the restroom situation, but also look at the broader issue of how transgender people feel on campus. This overall issue has Safe Zone members considering advocating to have “gender identity” in the college’s non-discrimination statement.

   “Another subcommittee is going to be looking at the college’s non-discrimination statement to see if that truly encompasses everything [the] Safe Zone committee would like to see,” said Jennifer Rhodes, director of student activities.

  While all 34 of Washington’s community and technical colleges have a non-discrimination policy that includes sexual orientation, only eight colleges explicitly state gender identity and expression within their policy.

  An additional five schools include a reference to the Washington State Law for Freedom of Discrimination (RCW 49.60), but do not write out gender identity within the policy.

  Rebekka Brucker, president of Triangle Alliance, said unlike gay rights, transgender rights are often not pushed for by the club or the LGBTQ community. It’s something many club members call the “silent T-syndrome”.

  Restrooms are often seen as being one of the only segregated areas in our country, but as the “T” on LGBTQ becomes louder that may not be the case.
  While in her English class, Brucker’s instructor was discussing pronouns. “My instructor mentioned pronouns like he and she, but many people don’t know about gender neutral pronouns,” she said.

  For instance, Stillwell does not like to be described with words like “he” or “she,” but with gender neutral pronouns like “hir” or “zie”.

  Brucker is planning to have the club create pamphlets about gender expression and a chart of gender-neutral pronouns that can be passed out to initiate a dialogue.

  “Stereotypes keep a climate of ignorance and intolerance,” Brucker said.
  As of now, there is no specific policy regarding the use of restrooms and transgender people, but Christina Castorena, dean of student development and diversity advocacy, expects one may be created as a result of these conversations.

  Castorena tells students to notify a staff member if a male is in the woman’s restroom/shower, or vice versa.

  “Let that staff member explore and it may be a conversation with that person, and then determine what’s appropriate,” she said.

  She also encourages those that are male or female, but identify as the other gender to talk with her or other Safe Zone committee members.

  “We want to support them and be able to find a way for them to have access to a facility or a shower, so we’ll work something out,” said Castorena.

  Any policy changes or other solutions are to be discussed further and presented by Safe Zone in June.

..

I don't see anything in the article to convince me this person was transgender in the first place. It sounds to me like a college boy decided to dress up so he could sneak in and get pervy. I have no doubt that any trangender ladies present in the restroom would have been just as offended as the cisgender ones.

As Castorena points out, the behavior of someone who doesn't belong there will be apparent, and requires a bit of finesse to determine. Fortunately I believe that situations where a man has legitimately used crossdressing as a way to gain inappropriate access are *very* rare.

Talk about timing. I just deleted my A4a for the 4th and last time. Your essay was SPOT on. Talking to one dude off of a4a. Had a nice romantic night. Left went home and just decided to check a4a to see his last log in - a few hrs after I left. Why is logging into a4a so early a priority? Those sites are for anti-social guys and bored people. They do create depression, addiction, insecurity and suspicion (that's me).I am leaving it to chance - let's us meet naturally face to face - flirt to flirt not chime to chime. Ever talk to someone on the phone and hear the a4a a chime? LMFAO!

As a person born Transsexual the word Transgender in instances like this should never be interchanged with the word Transsexual. Transgender is an Umbrella term and it does not mean a person born feeling they are the opposite sex only transsexuals and some intersex fit that category. In my state of residence Iowa, the gender identity law only covers a person with a valid gender identity that means the majority of people under the "Transgender Umbrella" or Transgender self identified would be violating the law to use the restroom of the opposite sex. The use of the word Transgender while being pushed in the media is not welcome by a large portion of the transsexual and intersex population and the LGBT is lying to you telling you it is okay to use their terminology on us. Speaking for myself if I enter any environment business or school and they use the word Transgender on me and refuse to acknowledge wrong doing for it I will sue them. It is time for the public to understand the LGBT does not either have all our support or our consent to claim to represent us and that it is a civil rights violation to force a political association (LGBT).

Truly upsetting. In the middle of great strides being made in transgender equality, we get one moron that does something like this. One episode like this can wipe out years of slow but steady progress, and casts a negative image of all transgenders. I would implore every transgender to conduct themselves in a moral and civilized manner, especially in sensitive areas such as this. Photographing women in a public restroom does not reflect the conduct of all transgenders, but it's likely that many will see it as such. In the words of Ghandi, "You must be the change you want to see in the world".
We cannot make people accept us, rather, we have to make people WANT to accept us. Conduct such as this is no way to achieve that.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Share the Clipper

Search

Syndicate

Syndicate content

Email us: Follow us: facebook icon  

Most Recent

  • Lunar New Year

    Date: 
    January 31, 2014 - 10:14pm

    Jan. 31 2014 is the Lunar New Year, in other words, the Chinese New Year. Here are some tips for you to use while enjoying your Lunar New Year.

    Traditions

    Greeting:

  • The hard working role model

    Date: 
    January 31, 2014 - 7:30am

    There has been a large pool of talented and skilled athletes this year in EvCC athletics. On the men’s basketball team, point guard David Ware has been a standout player for the Trojans this season.

  • 'Fauna Shade' make 'Sound Off!'

    Date: 
    January 31, 2014 - 7:29am

    So I’m carrying a bass drum up a wheelchair ramp in a dingy little venue in downtown Everett. I have no idea where I’m going or what I’m doing. Needless to say, I’ve never played at a paying concert before and I’m incredibly nervous. Looking over my shoulder, I notice a familiar face. To my surprise, I see the guy who sold me my textbooks a week before.

  • Macklemore wins Best Rap Album, students unhappy

    Date: 
    January 31, 2014 - 7:10am

    In case you missed it, Macklemore married a bunch of people at the Grammys, won four of his six nominations and apologized to Kendrick Lamar for taking Best Rap Album. The Clipper found out what the students think.

  • EvCC to host robotics competition

    Date: 
    January 15, 2014 - 12:52pm

    EvCC will be hosting an annual robotics competition on Saturday, Jan. 25 in Whitehorse from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.

Follow us @clipperonline!

More multimedia